top of page

Finding the Signal in the Noise: A Data Scientist's Approach

Writer: Harold Bell
Harold Bell
Apr 9
4 min read

Updated: Oct 29

Mayor Webster Lincoln's day job before politics was in digital pathology at Genentech. Finding meaningful signals in complex diagnostic data. His work literally involved looking at enormous amounts of information and determining what actually mattered for patient outcomes.


Politics, as anyone who's watched a news cycle knows, is the opposite of clean data. It's noise, emotion, agenda, spin, and counter-spin. All happening simultaneously.


On Magnetic, I asked Mayor Lincoln how he applies the same analytical discipline from his scientific career to cutting through political noise and focusing his constituents on what actually matters. His answer offers a framework that's directly applicable to B2B marketing and communications.



What does finding the signal in the noise mean?


The core insight is about signal identification under conditions of uncertainty. In pathology, you're looking at tissue samples where the signal (a disease marker) is embedded in an enormous amount of healthy tissue. In politics, the signal (the issue that will actually improve people's lives) is embedded in an enormous amount of performative debate, partisan positioning, and media-driven controversy.


Mayor Lincoln's discipline is to constantly return to the data as his North Star to find the signal in the noise. Not opinion polls. actual outcome data. What are the measurable conditions in his community? What interventions have evidence of effectiveness? What can he point to that's concrete, verifiable, and connected to the lived experience of his constituents?



How does this apply to B2B marketing?


For B2B marketers, this discipline translates to staying anchored in customer outcomes rather than getting swept up in market noise. It's easy to get distracted by what competitors are announcing, what analysts are predicting, or what keywords are trending. But the signal that drives real pipeline isn't in any of those places. It's in your customers' actual experience of the problem you solve.



Partner Over Product, a playbook for winning deals without losing the plot, by Harold Bell. Available on Amazon.


How do you stay on the issue that matters?


Mayor Lincoln also addresses something that I think every communicator struggles with. The tension between speaking to the issue that's trending and speaking to the issue that matters. Sometimes those are the same thing. Often, they're not. The discipline to stay on the issue that matters, even when the audience is temporarily distracted by something flashier, is what separates leaders from followers in any field. Content marketing measurement covers more.


His approach isn't about ignoring the noise. It's about processing it systematically, the way a scientist processes data. Filter out the outliers, identify the patterns, and focus your communication on the findings that will drive the best outcomes.


For marketing teams drowning in competitive intelligence, social listening data, and analyst reports, Mayor Lincoln's framework is a relief. You don't need to respond to everything. You need to identify the signal that connects your solution to your customer's actual problem, and then communicate that signal with relentless clarity.



How do you separate signal from noise in marketing data?


Start with the outcome your customers care about and work backward. Every data source, whether it's competitive intelligence, social listening, analyst reports, or campaign metrics, should be judged by whether it tells you something about that outcome. Data that doesn't connect to it is noise, however interesting it is.


Then look for patterns rather than spikes. A competitor announcement or a trending keyword is a single data point. Repeated themes in sales calls, support tickets, and win-loss interviews are a pattern, and patterns are what deserve a place in your messaging.


Finally, decide what you won't respond to. Most marketing teams don't need to react to every competitor move or industry headline. Choosing what to ignore frees up the attention to communicate the signal clearly.



Mastering AI Visibility by Harold Bell, The Demand Doctrine edition covering AI SEO, AEO, GEO, and LLMO. All four engines, one book. Available November 18th at demanddoctrine.com.


Want to watch the full conversation?


Watch this clip if you've ever felt paralyzed by information overload. Mayor Lincoln's scientific approach to communication can be summarized as data driven storytelling that cuts through the noise in a way that will change how you prioritize your messaging.



Mayor Webster Lincoln talks about his background as a data scientist


Frequently asked questions


What does finding the signal in the noise mean?

It means identifying the information that actually drives outcomes and setting aside everything that only competes for attention. Mayor Webster Lincoln learned the discipline in digital pathology, where a disease marker hides in a large amount of healthy tissue, and applies it to cutting through political noise.


How do B2B marketers find the signal in market noise?

Stay anchored in customer outcomes. Competitor announcements, analyst predictions, and trending keywords are easy distractions. The signal that drives pipeline lives in your customers' actual experience of the problem you solve, which shows up in sales calls, support tickets, and win-loss interviews.


Should marketing teams respond to every competitor move?

No. Most competitor announcements and industry headlines don't change what your customers need. Respond when a move affects the problem you solve or how buyers evaluate you. Otherwise, keep communicating the message that connects your solution to your customer's real problem.


What is the difference between a trending issue and an important one?

A trending issue captures attention right now. An important issue affects outcomes over time. Sometimes they overlap, but often they don't. The discipline is staying on the issue that matters even when the audience is temporarily distracted by something flashier.


How does data-driven storytelling relate to signal and noise?

Data-driven storytelling is how you communicate the signal once you've found it. You lead with the human impact, then use the data that proves it. Filtering the noise first ensures the story is built on the evidence that actually matters.


Who is Mayor Webster Lincoln?

Webster Lincoln is the mayor of East Palo Alto, California, and a data scientist who built his career at Genentech analyzing diagnostic data in digital pathology. He appeared on MQL Magnet's Magnetic interview series to talk about communication, messaging, and leadership.

bottom of page